A website redesign is easy to sell and easy to regret. The new design looks modern, everyone approves it in a meeting, and then enquiries stay flat, because the things that actually bring customers were never part of the brief. Before you sign for a redesign, run through these eight checks. They take an afternoon, and they can save you from paying twice.
1. What is the redesign supposed to change?
A redesign needs a job, not just a look. Is the goal more enquiries, more online orders, fewer phone calls asking the same questions, or a site you can finally update yourself? Write the goal down in one sentence and ask the designer how each part of their proposal serves it.
If the proposal is mostly new colours and a new font, it is a restyle, not a redesign. A restyle has its place, but it should not be priced or promised as a growth project.
2. How does the current site perform on a phone?
Most of your visitors will meet the new site on a phone first, often on a slow connection. Open your current site on a phone and try to do the one thing a customer does most: find a price, book a service, or place an order. Count the taps. Note where you get stuck.
Take that list to the designer. The new site should make that journey shorter, not prettier. Buttons big enough to tap, forms short enough to finish, and a phone number or WhatsApp button that works on the first try are not details. For a small business, they are the site.
3. Will the new site load fast on a real connection?
A slow site loses visitors before they read a word. Speed is not a technical nicety, it is the first impression. Ask what the designer will do to keep the site fast: properly sized images, no unnecessary plugins or scripts, and caching set up correctly.
Ask how speed will be measured after launch, and on what kind of connection. A site that loads fast on the designer’s office wifi and slowly on a customer’s mobile data has not passed the test.
4. What happens to your existing search visibility?
If your current site already brings visitors from Google, a redesign can accidentally throw that away. Pages move, addresses change, and old links break. Ask the designer for a simple plan: which existing pages will be kept, which will be redirected to their new addresses, and how page titles and descriptions will be carried over or improved.
This is the check most often skipped, and the one most often regretted. A redesign that loses your existing search traffic has to earn it all back before it can grow anything new. Keeping what already works is part of the job, and it belongs in the written scope, not in a verbal promise.
5. Who writes the content, and is it written for customers?
A beautiful site with thin or borrowed content will not sell anything. Every service page should answer the questions a real customer asks: what you do, who it is for, how it works, what it costs to start, and how to contact you. Stock phrases and generic claims help nobody.
Ask who writes the content and whether you will approve it before launch. If the plan is to reuse your old text without checking it, say so now and budget time to fix it. Good content takes longer than good layouts, and it deserves the same attention.
6. Are the images real?
Customers trust photographs of real work, real products, and real people far more than generic graphics. A redesign full of placeholder imagery makes every business look the same, and it hides exactly what a customer wants to see.
Ask for real photos of your work wherever possible, and check that you have the right to use every image on the site. If new photography is needed, plan for it early. It is the part of a redesign that takes the longest to arrange and the easiest to leave until launch week.
7. Who owns the site, the domain, and the content when it is finished?
This check protects you after launch. You should own your domain name, your hosting account access, your content, and your images. You should be able to update basic text yourself, and you should know what ongoing costs exist and what they cover.
Ask for logins and ownership in writing before the final payment. A site you cannot access without paying the original designer every time is not your asset, whatever the invoice called it.
8. How will you know if it worked?
Agree on measurement before launch, not after. Pick a small set of numbers that match the goal from check one: enquiries per month, completed orders, calls from the site, or time spent on key pages. Record the current numbers first, so the new site has something honest to beat.
Set a review date, roughly a month after launch, to look at those numbers together. A designer who welcomes that review is confident in the work. A designer who avoids it is telling you something too.
The short version
A good redesign starts from a goal, protects your existing search traffic, works fast on a phone, uses real content and real images, and leaves you owning your own site. Everything else is decoration, and decoration alone is not worth a redesign budget.
That is how we approach web development at Digilistan, with design and search optimisation built into the same brief rather than added afterwards. If you are considering a redesign and want a second opinion on a quote you already have, contact us with the quote and your current site address, and we will go through these eight checks against it.
